Swaim's NFL Superbook/Pick 5 Preview for Week 11
Can the Bucs stay in the NFC South race as they visit Motown? Will the Jaguars get washed out at a rainy MetLife?

Austin Swaim
NFL, CFB, NBA, WNBA, NASCAR + GOLF

I'm happy to have a home for this breakdown, which I've had on Twitter this year. BookIt asked me if I had anything for their readers, and I definitely did.
This is my weekly breakdown here of my five picks for Superbook or "Pick 5" spread contests. They're massively growing in popularity, and there's a real strategy in ranking confidence in spreads and understanding where the public is going to play.
Here are my five contest plays for Week 11 -- as well as some that missed the cut on the sharp side or the donkey side.
Week 10 Recap
Week 10 Contest Record: 2-3
Vikings +2.5 ✅
Colts -4.5 ❌
Titans +10.5 ❌
Cowboys +3.5 ❌
Chargers +4.5 ✅
Article Picks (Five Spreads and Alt Plays): 4-5
Year-to-Date Contest Recap: 27-23
Superbook Picks for Week 11
Note: Plays are sorted in order of confidence. My contest doesn't allow Thursday or international games.
Buccaneers +3.5
Even if this were a pick 'em, it'd still be in my five somewhere.
Tampa Bay's defense is one of the few good ones in the NFL, and it's elite. Moreover, they are a top-five run defense by most metrics (again), and stopping Jahmyr Gibbs is stopping the Detroit Lions.
Gibbs had just 74 yards and a touchdown in Miami, and this team scored 19 points. That was Miami's secondary. Not one that turned over Caleb Williams four times before their bye.
Speaking of that bye, it's an important 7 extra days for Baker Mayfield's thumb against the 24th-ranked pass defense. Most of that ranking was with Aidan Hutchinson speeding up the clock, too. The foot injury might actually help limit some of these inefficient Baker scrambles, too.
We buy Tampa. We buy Houston. Thems the rules here.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Buccaneers +3.5 | -110 | 2.2U |
Saints +11.5
I am genuinely surprised I'm the only one on this side. Of the double-digit underdogs this week, the Saints are easily the best team with plenty to play for.
Last week's tough loss still has them just one out in the NFC South, and I think they're okay by the division's standards. The defense has improved to 19th in EPA per play allowed, and the offense has to be a buy when Jordyn Tyson -- the draft's top receiver -- has 15 catches in two games.
Chicago is an excellent team. They're my current NFC pick for the Super Bowl. There's just a bit of variance in Ben Johnson's compulsion to go for 4th downs, and the secondary isn't extremely trustworthy.
I've long called Tyler Shough the next Blake Bortles. Once you get him down 17 against a soft zone, he might as well be Joe Montana. That backdoor will be wide open when first-half weather should stifle offense overall, then open up in the second stanza.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Saints +11.5 | -100 | 2U |
Vikings +3.5
I already see the narratives forming. The Vikings trained at sea level. Brock Purdy is excellent against the blitz.
Stop.
You're telling me that the team that just blew out Jordan Love and the red-hot Packers is an underdog again? Against a team with one of the highest stocks in the NFL? San Francisco just averaged 9.4 yards per play in an NFL game!
Purdy isn't close to as hot as Love was. He's had five turnover-worthy plays in his last three games, and all three of San Fran's huge plays last week were college-level throws for him. This is the deep end.
Plus, the Niners' secondary gave up a 40-spot to Dallas, and they've slipped to 16th against the pass. No Jordan Addison isn't ideal for Minny, but Justin Jefferson, TJ Hockenson, and a Jauan Jennings revenge game will do.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Vikings +3.5 | -110 | 1.65U |
Giants +5.5
It's insane how far the G-Men's stock has fallen in two weeks -- and really on one drive.
If Jayden Daniels doesn't make the comeback, this is probably a 3.5-point spread. In that individual game, all of their offensive stars played well, but Daniels is a tough matchup for their aggressive defensive line.
Trevor Lawrence can be, but he's run just 25 times this year. Instead, I think the Giants' pass rush (5th in win rate) can be a destructive problem against a team that hasn't faced a real pass rush since the Texans.
Speaking of that, let's pump the brakes on Jacksonville. They've faced Daniel Jones, Joe Fagnano, and the Titans -- who were ultra competitive into last week's fourth quarter -- in three straight. You've seen "historic" thrown around by Kay Adams and Danny Parkins with them this week. We call that "regression" around these parts.
Good luck to the warm-weather Jags at a windy, cold, rainy MetLife.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Giants +5.5 | +100 | 1.5U |
Eagles +3.5
I get to do a lot of my favorite things here. I get to fade the public. I get to fade Aaron Rodgers at a million years old. I get to fade Mike McCarthy as a road favorite.
It's all good news, and that's all the Eagles have gotten during a much-needed bye week, too. While motivation is still a question mark for the totally deep-fried Birds, they are much healthier with Saquon Barkley and DeVonta Smith back practicing in full. That, plus two weeks of practice, should help Joe Milton III in his second start.
Milton clearly flashed with his arm and his legs, but there were too many negative plays. I get the concern for more, given Pittsburgh's front against an Eagles offensive line that has struggled all year.
But, the Steelers' implosion last week was a long time coming. They have no vertical passing element. They're just 14th against the pass on an EPA-per-play basis.
Similar to Detroit, Philadelphia is 7th in run stuff win rate. If you shut down Jaylen Warren, this offense has zero chance.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Eagles +3.5 | -100 | 1.5U |
Last Ones Out for Week 11: Sharp Side
Broncos -10.5
This is probably a game where diving in after UFC on the weekends costs me.
A better key number for the Raiders' team total (14.5) existed, but at 14.5, I'll pass. I planned to be on it until Fernando Mendoza proved me otherwise, and oddsmakers caught on quickly.
After the Seahawks put a spy on Mendoza, the Raiders' offense was abysmal. Brock Bowers is likely out again. Now, he's on the road against a Broncos pass rush on the ascent in Jonathon Cooper's fourth game back.
Laying 10.5 with Bo Nix, who regularly sleepwalks through first halves, is the opposite of smart, though. Instead, I'm really just all about Jonah Coleman salting this clock away against Las Vegas' 24th-ranked rush defense, which is wearing down by the week.

Cowboys -7.5
I still think Dallas is the best team in the NFC East.
Mike Pettine might be able to help this defense reach a 32nd-place standard. Not worse than that like they've been. Under Christian Parker, the belief clearly dissipated. There were things going on last week that aren't possible for a defense with the talent they undeniably have.
As mentioned in survivor picks this week, Dallas has covered at a 55.6% clip as a home favorite since the start of 2023. They usually beat the crap out of bad teams at home, yet Tampa Bay and Arizona have won outright twice, fitting that description.
This is a ridiculous team total for Tennessee. They've posted 24-plus points just nine times since the start of 2024! Look for the Cowboys to control the tempo and limit chances.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| OVER UNDER | Titans Under 24.5 Points | -125 | 2U |
Last Ones Out for Week 11: Donkey Side
Chiefs -16.5
The Arizona Cardinals are fielding a UFL team on Sunday.
There's not really any other way to put it. Trey McBride is the lone hope for an offense otherwise starting Josh Johnson, who has made it through 1 full game injury-free since the start of 2022. Plus, their defense has tanked to 14th against the run and 32nd against the pass.
You will never catch me laying this many points in any capacity. I don't want the Chiefs up 27-3 and losing my bet on a backdoor that literally no one in the game cares about, and that's a substantial risk here and in Buffalo.
Can K.C. get to 16 at halftime? Because I'm fairly certain Arizona's ceiling is a pair of field goals (6) before the break, but a 0 or 3 are much, much more likely.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Chiefs -9.5 in First Half | -110 | 1.65U |
Chargers -3.5
Man, it took one week for the Bolts to be public darlings!
I'm thankful they temporarily eased the public onslaught with an outright win on MNF, but facing Geno Smith, bettors are back at the window.
I partially think it's fair. Omarion Hampton finally got going, and the Jets' rush D is 22nd (and sinking). Ladd McConkey could be back for L.A., but I care more about Tre Harris' breakout, which gives Herbert a reliable target.
Smith and Cade Klubnik combined to feed 14 targets to Garrett Wilson last week, and the Chargers' corners have been awful all year.
The Jets' RB duo is nice. Really, what's compromised their overs in the last two weeks were 8 field goals. L.A. has the 10th-worst rate of allowing red zone touchdowns (63.6%) over every team's respective last three games.
On a crummy week for weather almost everywhere, I want to root for one over. Indoors at SoFi will do.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| OVER UNDER | Over 42.5 Points | +100 | 1.5U |
If you're new to me, I'm an experienced multisport analyst who has been featured on FanDuel Research, numberFire, PrizePicks Playbook, Home of Fight, and more. If you enjoyed this piece, drop me a follow on X or TikTok at the username @ASwaim3.
I'm currently a free agent for a full-time job in editing or writing sports, sports betting, or fantasy sports content. Years ago, I left the accounting field to pursue this, which I've been doing on a freelance basis since I was 15. All of my UFC content, including my predictive model, is for sale to anyone who wants high-level content.
As McDonald's CEO Chris Kempczinski once said, "No one cares more about your career than you."
Thank you for reading and supporting my next chapter.

Official Picks by Austin Swaim
















| Game | Type | Pick | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() ![]() TB @ DET11/22 – 6:00 PM EDT | Spread | Buccaneers +3.5 | -110 | 2.2U |
![]() ![]() NO @ CHI11/22 – 6:00 PM EDT | Spread | Saints +11.5 | -100 | 2U |
![]() ![]() MIN @ SF11/23 – 1:20 AM EDT | Spread | Vikings +3.5 | -110 | 1.65U |
![]() ![]() JAX @ NYG11/22 – 9:25 PM EDT | Spread | Giants +5.5 | +100 | 1.5U |
![]() ![]() PIT @ PHI11/22 – 6:00 PM EDT | Spread | Eagles +3.5 | -100 | 1.5U |
![]() ![]() TEN @ DAL11/22 – 6:00 PM EDT | O/U | Titans Under 24.5 Points | -125 | 2U |
![]() ![]() ARI @ KC11/22 – 6:00 PM EDT | Spread | Chiefs -9.5 in First Half | -110 | 1.65U |
![]() ![]() NYJ @ LAC11/22 – 9:05 PM EDT | O/U | Over 42.5 Points | +100 | 1.5U |






