Swaim's NFL Superbook/Pick 5 Preview for Week 10
How should we handle the Colts after this week’s fire sale? Does Kirk Cousins take the Vikings to the next level?

Austin Swaim
NFL, CFB, NBA, WNBA, NASCAR + GOLF

I'm happy to have a home for this breakdown, which I've had on Twitter this year. BookIt asked me if I had anything for their readers, and I definitely did.
This is my weekly breakdown here of my five picks for Superbook or "Pick 5" spread contests. They're massively growing in popularity, and there's a real strategy in ranking confidence in spreads and understanding where the public is going to play.
Here are my five contest plays for Week 10 -- as well as some that missed the cut on the sharp side or the donkey side.
Week 9 Recap
Week 9 Contest Record: 2-3
Ravens +3.5 ✅
Eagles +3.5 ❌
Vikings +3.5 ❌
Broncos -2.5 ✅
Chargers +5.5 ❌
Article Picks (Five Spreads and Alt Plays): 5-4
Year-to-Date Contest Recap: 25-20
Superbook Picks for Week 10
Note: Plays are sorted in order of confidence. My contest doesn't allow Thursday or international games.
Vikings +2.5
It was disappointing not to even get the Week 1 version of Carson Wentz last week against an awful Bills defense, but the position has been stabilized.
Kirk Cousins immediately slots into a comfortable offense, and I’m not worried he’ll at least be able to propel a sneaky effective ground game into viability. Green Bay is second in YPC allowed, so it’ll be tough sledding either way.
At some point, this Packers passing game has to come back to Earth. Matthew Golden and Christian Watson are two of the top four in receiving yards over expectation despite a boatload of drops. Josh Jacobs is out a game, and a one-dimensional offense opposite Brian Flores’ blitz packages could look a lot like…Week 1’s second half, where the Pack mightily struggled.
Green Bay is second in the NFL in turnover differential (+8), but they’re not better than Minnesota. We’ll fade the team above them in that category, too.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Vikings +2.5 | -110 | 2.2U |
Colts -4.5
I know that a lot of the peripheral, nice pieces that make the Colts an average-to-good team are gone. DeForest Buckner, Quentin Nelson, and Josh Downs aren’t easy dudes to replace and still be good.
Luckily, just a standard, bad team will work here, and that’s Daniel Jones, Jonathan Taylor, Tyler Warren, and a mediocre defense that competed with Dallas last week.
Miami was a bottom-three team before turning to Kyle McCord. Now? They’re a projected three-and-out factory, which will sap the effectiveness of a surprisingly functional defense that’s also now missing Zach Sieler for the year.
The Dolphins saw the Cardinals and Chargers and realized they needed to act if they wanted Drew Mestemaker. So, all of a sudden, Malik Willis can’t play? Right…
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Colts -4.5 | -105 | 2.1U |
Titans +10.5
The Jaguars are frauds. You can choose not to believe me now, but I will not be wrong about this before the Lombardi Trophy is handed out in L.A.
In addition to Jacksonville ranking first in turnover differential (+9), which has propelled this tsunami, this team’s schedule luck has been unbelievable. Deshaun Watson’s first start in two years, Joe Fagnano, and the Colts right after starting the teardown…you’ll be lucky to get one of those spots in a year. Jacksonville got three — in addition to a patented Maye Meltdown™ compared to when the Pats’ QB plays like an MVP.
Their “all-in” splashes are a safety from one of the league’s worst secondaries and Jordan Davis, who just replaces DaVon Hamilton. This team still hasn’t played anyone real since losing Anton Harrison at left tackle for the year.
Giving away Amani Hooker, I’m mad at the Titans for not being at full strength in this spot, but this is simply a long-term winner. You don’t lay double digits on the road in any division, but Tennessee’s stock is up after recent competitive tilts. The hype is out of control.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Titans +10.5 | -110 | 1.65U |
Cowboys +3.5
Professional money is nuking the Cowboys this week, but I like them to win outright, so any number is fine.
San Francisco is 1st in offensive EPA per play but 18th in defensive EPA per play. Given that I know the former is propelled by Brock Purdy, the Niners are poised to collapse or demolish teams depending on his comfort, which usually parallels the strength of the defense he’s facing.
That sounds horrible against Dallas, but I quietly think their defense is getting into form. Indy is Indy, but they got swallowed for 4.6 yards per play. DeMarvion Overshown and Joey Porter Jr. are trending the right way for today’s game.
The Cowboys are also a team comfortable playing one-dimensional against the Niners’ stout run defense.
This line makes zero sense, but the Falcons +2.5 didn’t make any sense against Purdy on the road two weeks ago without Mike Evans, and they won outright by 9.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Cowboys +3.5 | +100 | 1.5U |
Chargers +4.5
I actually believe this week’s board is one of the worst of the year. Otherwise, the Chargers wouldn’t sniff this spot.
As mentioned a week ago before losing on L.A., I’m actually proud of myself that I’ve only been on them twice. That shellacking had more to do with CJ Stroud’s resurgence than a defense that’s still 11th in EPA per play.
I actually think getting to 4.6 yards per play against Houston, still a top-five defense in the NFL to me, is a sign of life for a Chargers offense that’s getting a little more clarity. Omarion Hampton is slowly more involved, and the pass game has Quentin Johnston and Tre Harris both back opposite a poor Ravens secondary.
Joe Fagnano sort of exposed the truth. What do the Ravens do well outside of Lamar and Zay Flowers? Jacksonville was able to salt away the clock last week with Ameer Abudallah (!) on the ground, their secondary has struggled for years, and Derrick Henry doesn’t look explosive one bit.
Jacoby Brissett went 3-4 ATS in Arizona, but I think this roster is worse. Henry is no Jeremiyah Love/Allgeier tandem. There’s no Trey McBride. It’s possible he can return them to functionality, but it — stunning — wouldn’t surprise anyone to see the Bolts win outright in a sloppy game. There’s motivation to avoid history with a single win.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Chargers +4.5 | -110 | 1.65U |
Last Ones Out for Week 8: Sharp Side
Texans -4.5
My biggest bet last week was the Browns. This week, we’re fading. That’s pro NFL gamblin’.
It’s a good spot to do so after Shedeur Sanders unearthed a bit of a ripple about the quarterback situation. I’d say the two played about evenly, but one of them is young and likable, and the other isn’t. Cleveland should probably play Shedeur to figure out if he’s the guy.
Maybe they do like him, and that’s why they’re not sending him out to face the post-bye Texans. Will Anderson Jr. and Danielle Hunter opposite this offensive tackle tandem, which has surrendered 33 sacks, is a no-contest. Jalen Pitre also returned against L.A.
The problem is the spot. Cleveland is 10-5 as a home underdog since the start of 2024. Offenses go into this building and short-circuit when the Browns are plus money. I’ve made so much coin on it.
So, let’s just fade Watson and assume the Browns’ defense bounces back. There’s still no David Montgomery to help Houston’s running game.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| OVER UNDER | Under 41.5 Points | -120 | 1.5U |
Seahawks -6.5
I’ve got a sneaking suspicion Fernando Mendoza is a bust. Call it a hunch, but professional bettors joined me in bumping this from 2.5 to 6.5 when he was announced as the starter.
Mendoza’s awful preseason was capped by a long wait through mediocrity for Kirk Cousins, culminating in a plummet to 4-5. I know the mouth service was to respect QB development from the entire organization, and Klint Kubiak’s leash is long, but it just seems odd.
I thought Mendoza was a decent QB prospect made out to be generational because people liked his goofy attitude, which isn’t built for winning, plus were starving for some “answer” at No. 1 overall for Vegas.
Seattle didn’t quite look right last week with Drew Lock against a reeling Arizona defense, but this Raiders D is awful. They’re 29th and sinking in EPA per play allowed.
I can’t take any under relying on Las Vegas’ D, but they don’t care about winning today. They care about getting Mendoza out of here with confidence, and that’s probably an ultra-conservative gameplan where he’s not asked to do much.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| PROP | Raiders Under 16.5 Points | 100 | 1.25U |
Last Ones Out for Week 8: Donkey Side
Panthers +2.5
The Panthers and Saints face off in a game where we’re pretending either has anything for the Bucs, and the sharps are at it again. I think they think the Saints are a lurking contender.
If you split it out, the Saints are 23rd in overall offensive EPA per play. On defense, they’re 21st against the run and 22nd against the pass. They’re bad at everything until Tyler Shough flings it to Chris Olave in garbage time. Luckily, it’s a great matchup for that.
Carolina just revitalized Bo Nix, and they’re giving up 344.9 yards per game (21st in the NFL). They’ve been smashed with injuries, trending toward being without Will Lee III and Jaelen Phillips today.
If there are two men built for a stressful, competitive shootout against a bad defense, it’s Shough and Bryce Young. Rather than sweat a late field goal on a public side, I’ll take the over.
| Type | Selection | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| OVER UNDER | Over 47.5 Points | -125 | 2U |
Chiefs -3.5
It’s never Kevin Stefanski. Certainly not at 3.5 points against Andy Reid.
My sharp friends are auto-clicking this bizarre sharp line in Atlanta, forgetting they lost on the Falcons last week in Madrid. I think it’s Chiefs or pass.
There’s a good reason to pass, though. Kenneth Walker’s groin injury is a concern when he’s been the heliocentric force on their offense. But, as I’ll get to in a moment, Emmett Johnson was one of my top-100 prospects in the draft, and he’s a three-down guy.
The Falcons just dealt Jessie Bates III, their cleaner-upper on the back end. He always was making key plays. No dice.
It’s very odd to me that sharps love Atlanta so much when K.C. is fourth in EPA allowed per rush, and if you bottle Bijan Robinson, this is a wholly limited team.
Johnson’s combo prop is sick against a defense that’s allowing the fifth-most fantasy points to RBs.

If you're new to me, I'm an experienced multisport analyst who has been featured on FanDuel Research, numberFire, PrizePicks Playbook, Home of Fight, and more. If you enjoyed this piece, drop me a follow on X or TikTok at the username @ASwaim3.
I'm currently a free agent for a full-time job in editing or writing sports, sports betting, or fantasy sports content. Years ago, I left the accounting field to pursue this, which I've been doing on a freelance basis since I was 15. All of my UFC content, including my predictive model, is for sale to anyone who wants high-level content.
As McDonald's CEO Chris Kempczinski once said, "No one cares more about your career than you."
Thank you for reading and supporting my next chapter.

Official Picks by Austin Swaim
















| Game | Type | Pick | Odds | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() ![]() MIN @ GB11/15 – 6:00 PM EDT | Spread | Vikings +2.5 | -110 | 2.2U |
![]() ![]() MIA @ IND11/15 – 6:00 PM EDT | Spread | Colts -4.5 | -105 | 2.1U |
![]() ![]() JAX @ TEN11/15 – 6:00 PM EDT | Spread | Titans +10.5 | -110 | 1.65U |
![]() ![]() SF @ DAL11/15 – 9:25 PM EDT | Spread | Cowboys +3.5 | +100 | 1.5U |
![]() ![]() LAC @ BAL11/17 – 1:15 AM EDT | Spread | Chargers +4.5 | -110 | 1.65U |
![]() ![]() HOU @ CLE11/15 – 6:00 PM EDT | O/U | Under 41.5 Points | -120 | 1.5U |
![]() ![]() SEA @ LV11/15 – 9:05 PM EDT | Prop | Raiders Under 16.5 Points | +100 | 1.25U |
![]() ![]() CAR @ NO11/15 – 6:00 PM EDT | O/U | Over 47.5 Points | -125 | 2U |






